The Hidden Perils of Counterfeit Olive Oil: Unveiling a History of Deception

Blog image created with Canva


The Hidden Perils of Counterfeit Olive Oil: Unveiling a History of Deception - by Joy Sypher

Old family story time. My grandfather and great grandmother stopped along the roadside circa 1940 and my grandfather plucked a green olive off a nearby tree. "Hey mom, you know those green olives in the jar you like so much? Here's a fresh one." My great grandmother took a bite, then spent 5 minutes shouting at my grandfather. Turns out fresh from the tree green, and probably unripe, do not taste the same as the ones in the jars.

I follow a historic food youtuber and olive oil is one of my favorite topics. I did some research and the counterfeit olive oil industry is alarming.

Olive oil, often referred to as "liquid gold," has been cherished for its health benefits, culinary versatility, and cultural significance for millennia. Its rich history dates back to ancient civilizations, where it was not only a dietary staple but also a symbol of prestige and luxury. However, the modern market for olive oil has become a double-edged sword, with the prevalence of fake or adulterated olive oil posing significant dangers to consumers. To understand the gravity of this issue, we need to delve into the history of olive oil and its nemesis, seed oils.

A Brief History of Olive Oil

The story of olive oil can be traced back over 6,000 years to the Mediterranean region, where it was initially cultivated and revered by civilizations like the ancient Greeks, Romans, and Egyptians. These ancient cultures recognized its culinary and medicinal properties and considered it a sacred gift from the gods.

Olive oil's popularity spread throughout the Mediterranean and into Europe, where it played a pivotal role in culinary traditions, from Italy's pasta sauces to Spain's paella. Olive oil was also utilized as a cosmetic, lamp fuel, and even as a form of currency.

The Age of Adulteration

As the demand for olive oil grew, so did the temptation for adulteration. In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, unscrupulous producers began to mix cheaper oils, such as sunflower and soybean oil, with olive oil to maximize profits. This practice marked the beginning of a long-standing issue that persists to this day.

Seed Oils: A History of Substitution

The introduction of seed oils as a substitute for olive oil further exacerbated the problem. Seed oils, like corn, soybean, and sunflower oil, are significantly cheaper to produce than genuine olive oil. Moreover, they can be easily blended with olive oil, making it difficult for consumers to detect fraud.

The rise of industrialization and globalization led to a proliferation of counterfeit olive oil, as seed oils could be easily shipped, stored, and disguised. These seed oils, while less healthy and less flavorful, became a popular substitute, endangering both consumer health and the reputation of genuine olive oil.

I remember begging my mom to switch to canola oil because it was healthier than corn or vegetable oil. I felt lied to and manipulated when I learned that solvents and deodorizers are used in the production of canola oil (rapeseed oil). Remember the 96% fat free margarine that was almost plastic with fake flavoring? That was my staple for years.

Dangers of Fake Olive Oil

Health Risks: Counterfeit olive oil is often blended with lower-quality oils, which can contain harmful trans fats and chemicals used in processing. Consuming these adulterated oils can lead to various health problems, including heart disease and obesity.

Taste and Culinary Experience: Authentic olive oil is prized for its distinct flavor and aroma. Fake olive oil not only lacks these qualities but can also ruin the taste of dishes. This affects the culinary heritage of Mediterranean cuisine and other global dishes that rely on olive oil.

Economic Impact: The prevalence of counterfeit olive oil negatively impacts genuine olive oil producers. Small-scale farmers and artisanal producers struggle to compete with cheaper, substandard products, potentially threatening their livelihoods.

Environmental Concerns: The mass production of seed oils has environmental consequences, including deforestation and habitat destruction. The demand for these oils, driven by fraudulent practices, indirectly contributes to these issues.

How to Identify Authentic Olive Oil

Recognizing genuine olive oil from its counterfeit counterparts can be challenging, but here are some tips to help consumers make informed choices:

  • Check for Certification: Look for seals of authenticity like the European Union's Protected Designation of Origin (PDO) or Protected Geographical Indication (PGI). These labels ensure that the olive oil is produced in specific regions known for their high-quality oil.
  • Examine the Bottle: Legitimate olive oil is often packaged in dark glass bottles to protect it from light, which can degrade the oil. Additionally, check for a harvest date and the producer's contact information.
  • Trust Your Senses: Authentic olive oil should have a distinct aroma and flavor. It should taste fruity, slightly bitter, and have a peppery finish. If it lacks these characteristics, be cautious.
  • Price Matters: Authentic olive oil is more expensive to produce than seed oils, so be skeptical of prices that seem too good to be true.

The history of olive oil is a testament to its enduring significance in human culture and cuisine. However, the prevalence of counterfeit olive oil and the history of seed oils being used as a substitute highlight the need for vigilance among consumers. To protect our health, culinary traditions, and the livelihoods of genuine olive oil producers, we must remain informed and discerning when choosing olive oil for our kitchens. By doing so, we can savor the true essence of "liquid gold" and preserve its legacy for generations to come.

I started my journey to heal from the inside out. Using real olive oil is one block and my foundation to better health.

Written by Joy Sypher
Published September 23rd, 2023

Social Media:
Twitter Joy
Twitter Roxana
Keto Coaching now offered worldwide

Highly recommended books: